Thursday, November 19, 2026

News & Politics

Appeals Court Hears Muscogee Nation’s Challenge to Tulsa Prosecutions of Non-Muscogee Native People

Three Tenth Circuit judges weighed whether the Tulsa County district attorney can charge Native people who aren't Muscogee citizens with minor crimes inside the reservation.

Staff Writer

Tribal Town Radio · November 18, 2026

2 min read
Illustration of a city skyline at dusk beside a river, under two overlapping translucent circles, one green and one gray.

Illustration: AI-generated

Attorneys for the Muscogee Nation and Tulsa County District Attorney Steve Kunzweiler argued before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on Tuesday, Nov. 17, in Muscogee Nation v. Kunzweiler. The case asks whether Tulsa prosecutors can charge Native people who are not Muscogee citizens with minor crimes inside the reservation, which covers most of Tulsa. A federal judge sided with Kunzweiler last year, and the Nation is asking the appeals court to reverse that ruling, according to KOSU reporting published with the Tulsa Flyer.

Riyaz Kanji, arguing for the Nation, pointed to the 1991 “Duro fix,” the law Congress passed to restore tribes’ authority to prosecute Native people on their reservations regardless of tribal affiliation. Kannon Shanmugam, arguing for Tulsa, said non-members are not constituents of the tribal government because they do not vote in tribal elections or use certain tribal services. KOSU reported that the three-judge panel appeared more receptive to the Nation’s position. No ruling has been issued.

The Cherokee, Chickasaw and Choctaw Nations have filed in support of the Muscogee Nation. In October, the Oklahoma Legislature approved $500,000 from the State-Tribal Litigation Fund for Kunzweiler’s legal team, spending Principal Chief David Hill criticized on social media. Whatever the panel decides, the outcome will shape who can be prosecuted, and by which government, across the reservation.

This summary was drafted with AI assistance from the reporting linked below. Read the full story at Tulsa Flyer.